THE POST
Bill McKibben, Michael Mann, Al Gore, the Sierra Club, the NRDC, Earthjustice, and Friends of the Earth are all opposed to the most meaningful energy abundance legislation in a generation. Who could have seen this coming.
ENGAGEMENT
- likes100
- reposts10
- replies5
- quote1
- bookmarks7
- views4,446
AS RETURNED BY THE X API · FETCHED 2026-11-12 06:19 UTC
WHAT IT SAYS
Alex Trembath lists Bill McKibben, Michael Mann, Al Gore, the Sierra Club, the NRDC, Earthjustice and Friends of the Earth as opponents of what he calls the most meaningful energy abundance legislation in a generation, the US permitting bill BAAJA, and suggests their opposition was predictable.
CONTEXT
The Senate voted 73 to 25 on 9 November to advance the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, which rewrites parts of NEPA, the Clean Water Act and the Endangered Species Act, gives permitted projects more certainty, and reforms the Federal Power Act. That was a vote to move to debate, not final passage. Several senators who voted yes want amendments, and the House still has to act.
NRDC says the transmission and grid provisions would produce substantial and durable benefits, but that the project-certainty language, narrower environmental review and limits on courts could favour fossil fuel and industrial projects. Latitude Media reports that the Sierra Club and Earthjustice share these concerns and that McKibben opposes the deal, while pro-build groups such as Third Way and the Searchlight Institute back it. I did not find sources for the positions of Mann, Gore or Friends of the Earth, so those parts of the post are unverified here.
An early summary of Resources for the Future modelling, shared with Latitude Media, finds the bill would favour clean energy over fossil fuels on net, cut emissions through 2041 and lower system-wide electricity costs by 4% to 8%, through more long-distance transmission and faster interconnection. RFF notes its model can't capture some of the risks the green groups raise, or the boom in behind-the-meter gas at data centres.
WHAT IT MEANS FOR K
Permitting and transmission are where the US build is stuck, so a law that speeds both up would raise the rate at which watts get connected. Until it passes both chambers, it's a potential accelerator, not an actual one.
CLAIMS
- BAAJA is the most meaningful energy abundance legislation in a generation (Trembath).
- A list of climate figures and green groups opposes it (Trembath).
EVIDENCE
- The Senate advanced the bill 73 to 25; final votes and House action are pending (Senate EPW, Axios).
- NRDC supports the transmission title but calls other parts deeply flawed (NRDC).
- Early RFF modelling shows lower system costs and a net shift to clean energy (via Latitude Media).
REASONING
- The bill's design points at the real bottlenecks, transmission and slow reviews, which is why abundance advocates rank it so highly.
- The opposition Trembath highlights is real for NRDC, the Sierra Club, Earthjustice and McKibben, and it rests on specific objections rather than opposition to building in general.
- Nothing has been enacted, so the effect on harnessed power is still a forecast, which makes this speculative.
SEE ON THIS SITE
TAGS
- POLICY
- PERMITTING
- TRANSMISSION
- ABUNDANCE
- UNITED-STATES